Best Bites: A Guide to Dining Near Mangrove Marina
You might know that the Florida Keys have a culture of their own with a relaxed beachy vibe and laid-back island attitude. You might be less familiar with the Florida Keys’ food culture. We’re best known for diverse, fresh seafood offerings and delicious citrus treats. Whether you’re just passing through on a liveaboard or staying longer in one of our Aqua Villas, we present you with our Florida Keys dining guide and welcome you to enjoy some of the freshest, fiercest flavors in the Keys!
Must-Try Restaurants in the Florida Keys
1. Catch of the Day: What the Fish Rolls & More
Described as locally caught and ocean-to-table, What the Fish Rolls Seafood Shack might just be one of the best seafood restaurants near Mangrove Marina. Choose from calamari, shrimp, and conch, or splurge on seasonal favorites, like lobster and crab. For those who aren’t fans of seafood, the restaurant also offers several pork and chicken dishes, and you can enjoy a fresh slice on pizza nights every Friday and Saturday. This is also one of our favorite restaurants with waterfront views in the Keys.
2. Legendary Fish Sandwiches: Captain Craig’s
Since 1981, Captain Craig’s has been serving up some of the most creative sandwiches, making it another one of our must-try restaurants in the Florida Keys. Choose from fresh, locally caught mahi-mahi, yellowtail, and grouper or chicken and steak paired with salads bursting with flavor and the coldest beer in the Keys.
3. Pizza Parties: Krust Pizza and Pies
Krust is a family-owned and operated pizza shop featuring exciting pizza combos. Ingredients are premier and include various meats, cheeses, and sauces with flavorful add-ons, like hot honey and pepper flakes. After dinner, check out their selection of pies, including Key Lime, Oreo, and Nutella.
4. A Taste of Cuba: Cuban Cuisine: Habanos on the Creek
Here you can find your standard Key faves, like conch fritters and lobster bites, as well as popular Cuban treats, like puerco frita and churrasco wraps. Delivery and carry-out ordering options make it easy for you to grab lunch or dinner on the go from one of the best restaurants near Tavernier or take it home and enjoy back at your houseboat rental or liveaboard. Either way, you’ll be enjoying some of Cuba’s most flavorful dishes from one of the best restaurants near Tavernier.
5. Fresh, Fun Dessert: The Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory
No visit to the Florida Keys is complete until you’ve had a cool, refreshingly light and creamy piece of Key Lime pie. Plenty of restaurants and shops carry pies here in Tavernier, but Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory specializes in this tiny tart citrus with desserts guaranteed to blow you away. Their pies have repeatedly won titles ranging from “Best in Key West” to “Best in Florida.” Choose from Key Lime Pie Cookies, Key Lime Pie candy, or frozen Key Lime Pie on a Stick! Before you go, keep in mind that the Blond Giraffe does not accept cash, so you’ll need to keep a major credit card or debit card on hand or use an alternative e-payment such as Cash App or Apple Pay.
Contact Mangrove Marina today to learn more or to make reservations for your next getaway!
